Investing Strategies

Sequence-of-Returns Risk: Why Early Retirement Losses Matter

By MissMiliMag Editorial Team··2 min read
Hands counting banknotes

Two portfolios can experience the same returns in a different order and finish with different balances when withdrawals are involved.

Average returns do not fully describe retirement risk. Sequence-of-returns risk is the danger that poor returns arrive when withdrawals force you to sell more assets, leaving less capital to participate in a later recovery. It is especially relevant around the start of regular portfolio withdrawals.

Why Order Changes the Result

Without deposits or withdrawals, multiplying the same periodic returns in a different order produces the same ending value. With cash moving in or out, the order matters.

Consider two hypothetical $100,000 portfolios, each withdrawing $10,000 at the end of each year. One earns minus 20% followed by plus 25%. It ends year one at $70,000 after the withdrawal, then year two at $77,500 after the next withdrawal. Reverse the returns and the ending balance is $82,000. Both experienced the same two returns, but withdrawals changed the result.

This simplified example excludes fees, taxes and inflation. Its purpose is to show the mechanism, not forecast retirement outcomes.

Build Flexibility Into Withdrawals

A spending plan can distinguish essential expenses from discretionary purchases. Temporarily reducing optional withdrawals after losses may preserve assets, though not everyone has that flexibility. Guaranteed income sources, where applicable, can change how much a portfolio must support.

A reserve of liquid, lower-volatility assets may help meet near-term spending needs without selling equities during a decline. The reserve's size should reflect actual obligations and the overall allocation; cash also has inflation and opportunity costs.

Diversification Helps but Cannot Eliminate It

Holding stocks, suitable bonds and cash can reduce dependence on a single source of returns. It does not guarantee that all assets will avoid losses together. Rebalancing, withdrawal timing and tax treatment also influence results.

Plan using a range of market paths, not just one average-return projection. Include a long retirement, changing healthcare costs and realistic inflation assumptions. Our portfolio diversification guide covers the foundation.

Further Reading

Investor.gov's resources for older investors offer additional planning considerations.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is sequence risk only a retirement problem?
No. It can affect any portfolio funding ongoing withdrawals, such as tuition or living costs.
Does a positive long-term average guarantee a safe withdrawal plan?
No. The order of returns, withdrawal size, inflation and investment costs all matter.
Note: This article is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice. See our Disclaimer.